Switching cosmetic contract manufacturers: does the product stay the same?

A new site can change the product even if the formula does not. Reference batches, written acceptance criteria and measuring the first new batches make the difference visible.

When you change contract manufacturer, the formula stays the same on paper, but only a comparison can show that the product did. That means securing reference batches and samples from the old site before the transfer, writing acceptance criteria in advance, and measuring the new site's first batches against the same criteria. Responsibility does not move with the site: it stays with the company placing the product on the market under its own brand.

If the formula is the same, why might the product change?

A recipe does not capture everything that determines the result. Moving from one site to another can change:

  • Equipment: mixing and homogenisation set-up, heating and cooling profile, tank scale.
  • Raw materials: the new site's approved suppliers. The same INCI name does not mean the same grade or the same impurity profile.
  • Utilities: water system, cleaning regime, filling temperature.
  • Packaging: the line, capping force, the primary pack supplier.

Not every product shows all of these effects. Emulsions, suspensions and high-active serums are often more sensitive than a simple aqueous solution. What matters depends on the product, so no single checklist fits everything.

What do the rules require when the site changes?

The GMP guideline of TİTCK, the Turkish regulator (KDD-KLVZ-01), has no separate section on technology transfer. Existing provisions have to be read together. The references below are to Türkiye's Regulation on Cosmetic Products; EU Regulation 1223/2009 follows a very similar structure.

ProvisionRequirementWhat it means for a site change
Regulation Articles 4 and 6The brand owner who has the product made is manufacturer and responsible personResponsibility stays with the brand owner
Regulation Article 13Safety report kept up to date with new informationChanges in stability, impurities or microbiology go to the assessor
Regulation Article 14Product information file covers the manufacturing method and GMP statement, updated as neededUpdate it for the new site
Regulation Article 16Notified information updated without delay if it changesCheck affected fields with your responsible technical person
Annex I/B Part AComposition, physical and chemical properties, stability, microbiology, impuritiesThese set the comparison headings
GMP section 14Written contract for each contract operationThe new contract should include acceptance criteria
GMP 13.2.11Written procedures and records for change controlManage the transfer through a change record

We set out the wider responsibility picture in contract manufacturing responsibility. This article deals only with the transfer itself.

Who does what, and in what order?

  1. Secure the records before the old relationship ends. Formula, manufacturing instructions, specifications, critical process parameters, batch records, approved supplier list. The GMP guideline requires batch records to be kept for at least one year after expiry (13.2.10), and retained samples likewise (12.4.1). You may lose access when the contract ends, so write the handover into it in advance.
  2. Choose reference batches. One batch does not show natural variation. Pick several trouble-free batches from the old site, take retained samples into your own hands, and measure them.
  3. Write acceptance criteria before the first production run. Which range applies to which parameter, and who decides on a deviation? A range written afterwards invites argument.
  4. Measure the new site's first batches. A pilot batch may not represent industrial scale, so include the first full-scale batches in the plan.
  5. Assess and record. If the difference is within range, close the change record. If it is not, adjust the process or go to the safety assessor.
  6. Keep the two sites apart during the transition. Products from both can be on the market at once. Batch numbering should show which site each batch came from, which is where batch identity matters.

What should be compared?

HeadingExample parametersWhy it matters
Physical and chemicalAppearance, colour, odour, pH, viscosity, densityProcess differences often show here first
Component profileActive level, product profile against the referenceBasis for claims and batch identity
MicrobiologyMicrobiological specification, preservation efficacy test where relevantWater system and hygiene differences
StabilityBehaviour under reasonably foreseeable storage conditionsShelf life and period-after-opening statements
ImpuritiesArising from raw material from new suppliersPurity information in the safety report
Pack compatibilitySealing, interaction with the productNew line and pack supplier

Not every parameter is needed for every product. If the formula, raw material sources and pack all stay the same, the scope can narrow, but the rationale should be in writing. Decide with your safety assessor whether new stability work is needed, since the report goes out under the assessor's signature.

Frequently asked questions

Can I take the formula to the new site? That depends on the old contract and who owns the formula. If a ready-made base formula was used, rights may have stayed with the manufacturer. Get legal advice and build the transfer plan around it.

Does the new site's GMP certificate replace the comparison? No. A certificate tells you about the site's system; it does not show that your product comes out the same as earlier batches.

Do I need to notify the product again? Article 16 of the Turkish regulation requires notified information to be updated without delay if it changes. Your responsible technical person should check which field is affected and whether anything further is needed in the national system.

Where does Kozvex fit in the transfer?

In Kozvex, an approved batch is defined as a reference and later batches are compared against it. Because the reference belongs to your product, it is assessed by the same measure whichever site makes it, and you hold a record independent of the contract manufacturer's statement. Scanning is done with the handheld device and mobile app; where a decision is needed, the sample goes to a contracted accredited laboratory. The record does not replace stability work, the safety assessment or the contract. Detail is on the how we work and skincare pages.

Sources

Meeting request

Let us define which batches and raw materials you will measure.

The first meeting reviews your product, sales channels and the risks you face, and recommends a suitable method.

Request a meeting